🔗 Share this article

During a preview for Simon Cowell's latest Netflix project, there is a moment that seems almost nostalgic in its adherence to past eras. Perched on various tan couches and formally clutching his knees, Cowell talks about his aim to curate a fresh boyband, two decades following his pioneering TV talent show launched. "This involves a huge danger with this," he states, laden with drama. "Should this fails, it will be: 'Simon Cowell has lost his touch.'" But, as those familiar with the declining ratings for his current series recognizes, the more likely response from a significant majority of contemporary 18- to 24-year-olds might instead be, "Simon who?"

The Central Question: Can a Music Figure Adapt to a Digital Age?

However, this isn't a younger audience of fans cannot drawn by Cowell's track record. The issue of whether the veteran executive can tweak a stale and decades-old formula is not primarily about present-day music trends—a good thing, since pop music has mostly shifted from TV to arenas such as TikTok, which he admits he hates—and more to do with his extremely well-tested capacity to produce good television and bend his persona to fit the times.

In the publicity push for the project, Cowell has made an effort at expressing contrition for how cutting he was to contestants, saying sorry in a prominent publication for "his past behavior," and attributing his eye-rolling demeanor as a judge to the monotony of audition days as opposed to what many saw it as: the mining of amusement from confused aspirants.

Repeated Rhetoric

Regardless, we've heard this before; He has been making these sorts of noises after fielding questions from journalists for a good fifteen years now. He made them years ago in the year 2011, during an interview at his rental house in the Beverly Hills, a residence of minimalist decor and empty surfaces. During that encounter, he discussed his life from the perspective of a bystander. It appeared, then, as if he viewed his own personality as operating by external dynamics over which he had little influence—warring impulses in which, naturally, occasionally the less savory ones prevailed. Regardless of the result, it came with a resigned acceptance and a "It is what it is."

This is a babyish excuse typical of those who, following very well, feel no obligation to account for their actions. Yet, there has always been a liking for Cowell, who merges US-style hustle with a uniquely and intriguingly odd duck personality that can really only be British. "I'm a weird person," he said then. "I am." His distinctive footwear, the funny style of dress, the awkward presence; all of which, in the context of Los Angeles conformity, still seem vaguely charming. You only needed a glimpse at the empty mansion to ponder the challenges of that specific interior life. While he's a difficult person to work with—it's likely he can be—when Cowell discusses his openness to all people in his orbit, from the doorman to the top, to come to him with a good idea, it seems credible.

The Upcoming Series: An Older Simon and New Generation Contestants

The new show will introduce an older, softer iteration of Cowell, if because he has genuinely changed today or because the cultural climate expects it, it's hard to say—but this shift is signaled in the show by the inclusion of his longtime partner and brief views of their 11-year-old son, Eric. While he will, likely, hold back on all his old critical barbs, many may be more curious about the contestants. Namely: what the gen Z or even gen Alpha boys trying out for the judge understand their function in the series to be.

"There was one time with a guy," he recalled, "who came rushing out on stage and proceeded to shouted, 'I've got cancer!' Treating it as a triumph. He was so elated that he had a heartbreaking narrative."

At their peak, Cowell's reality shows were an initial blueprint to the now common idea of mining your life for content. The difference these days is that even if the aspirants vying on the series make similar calculations, their online profiles alone guarantee they will have a greater ownership stake over their own narratives than their counterparts of the mid-2000s. The ultimate test is whether Cowell can get a countenance that, similar to a famous broadcaster's, seems in its default expression naturally to express disbelief, to project something warmer and more friendly, as the era seems to want. And there it is—the impetus to tune into the premiere.